Skip to main content

Can a sitting CM be arrested?

What are legal and constitutional provisions regarding arrest of a sitting CM ?



















The arrest of Delhi CM has raised the point of loopholes in Indian legal and constitutional system.

Let's understand what Indian Constitution say about arrest of a sitting CM and what if a arrested CM wants to run the Government from jail.

The arrest of Delhi CM Arvind Kejriwal has raised a constitutional debate. The such kind of arrest is not first in India. Earlier also the then sitting CM like Jayalalithaa (T.N), Lalu Prasad Yadav ( Bihar) and Jharkhand CM Hemant Soren has been arrested. 
The constitution provides immunity from arrest for act done while performing the duties to sitting President and Governor under article 361. But in case of sitting PM and CM there is no such or any other shielding provided by the constitution. PM and CM are treated equal to other citizens and here the constitution follows the equality before law and equal protection of law concept under article 14.
Therefore, a sitting CM or PM can be arrested. Yes, sitting CM can be arrested for investigation of allegations. Now, here comes another question that if a CM is arrested, will he or she be disqualified? The answer is that merely arrested does not make the disqualification. 
The representation of people act 1951 put conviction as the necessary condition for a sitting CM to be disqualified. So, if he or she will not be disqualify till proven guilty, Can he or she run the Government from jail?
It depends upon the CM that he wants to be continue as CM or not till the investigation is going on. Let's take example of the recent Delhi CM case. If he wants to remain CM, he can do so but practical challenges come here. Will the cabinet meeting be allowed in jail? How, he manage the law and order situations from jail. Definitely he has public mandate but administrative work, welfare activities and law and order must not be affected. So, if investigation run longer, he should resign. If he doesn't resign, then it is impractical to run the Government from jail. Then, here, in case of Delhi, comes the role of Lieutenant Governor. In this scenario the Lieutenant Governor can seek centre government intervention through recommending for implementation of President rule.
Labels:

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

How to save Indian social values system

India heading towards Socio-cultural changes, Need to save the core values of the Indian society. These values are the identities of our culture. In today's Indian society there are many changes taking place. Every society change in years. But, how can we say that a society is changing. What are the symptoms of this change. Every society has its value system which it preserve for years by passing it generation to generation. Then, what are the core values of Indian society ? The core values of Indian society are : respecting and obeying elders, cooperation, brotherhood, sharing of resources, careing and helping each other etc. One learns all these values in a joint family. A joint family is a big family where four -five nucleus families living together. A joint family is the custodian of the Indian social value system. In today's society, we are witnessing a noticeable decay of these values. Why so? This is because of fastly decrease in joint families. Today we rarely see a joi...
1 comment
Read more

The question of 90 hour work week

Is 90 hour work- week sustainable? It will enhance the crony capitalism and damage the democracy. The 90 hour work-week is highly debate able after the L&T Chairman's statement. Many Chairmans and CEOs of the top institutions give their responses. Some employees also give reactions on social media. Maximum top executives favour longer hours week and almost all employees wants five days work week. Both have their own point of view. But let's analyse what is good for the country. First take the top executives view that there must be 90 hour work week. They give logic that India is a developing country and if we want to make it developed by 2047, we have to work more and more. They are citing the national agenda of being a developed country by 2047.  Working 90 hour a week means working 15 hours a day from Monday to Saturday. It raises many questions like - Can one work for 15 hours a day countinue for whole week and so on? Can the employees will be paid for these 15 hours, me...
2 comments
Read more

Who is responsible for poor public services in India?

What is the actual reason for poor public services in India? Nowadays it is a common trend to say that government employees are ' kaamchor ' (don't want to work). We can easily see long queues in front of any government offices like  tehsils, passport offices, banks, railway stations, hospitals etc. The person who gets poor service blame the staff of that particular department or office. Government also think that the staff is not performing well and launched campaign to aware the people about their rights. It is very good to be aware about the rights and government is also doing good in spreading the awareness. Then where is the problem? Are today's employees really not interested in doing work ?  Dear readers also have the right to be agree or disagree but let's try to understand the problem genuinely. Today's an awared customer put complaint if any service is not provided. But nobody bothered about the circumstances due to which the service is not provided. I...
Post a Comment
Read more